Navigating Garage Door Openers: Chain vs. Belt vs. Screw Drive vs. Jackshaft
Posted by Action Direct on 26th Mar 2024
Garage door openers all serve the purpose of opening and shutting your door, but not all models are created equal. Between chain, belt, screw drive, and jackshaft openers, each has different costs, noise levels, setup requirements, and more. What’s best for you is largely dependent on what you want to get out of an opener, and what works depends on your garage set up. Action Direct’s experts have decades of experience in the industry, so read on to learn the pros and cons of each main opener and which is best for you!
What are The Four Main Types of Garage Door Openers?
There are four main types of garage door openers, appropriately named after what components make them unique:
-
Chain drives are a reliable and cost-effective choice. They rely on a chain to lift or lower a garage door. While they may produce more noise compared to other types of openers, their durability and affordability make them a popular choice for many homeowners.
-
Belt drive garage door openers function the same as chain drives, only as the name implies, they use a belt in place of a chain. Belt drives offer quiet and reliable performance, making them an excellent choice for homeowners seeking a more peaceful garage door operation. While they may be more expensive than chain drive systems, their benefits in terms of noise reduction and reliability often justify the higher cost.
-
Screw drive systems utilize a threaded steel rod (or screw) to move the door along its track. Screw drive garage door openers are reliable and efficient. They require minimal maintenance in the right conditions, and are suitable for various garage setups. However, homeowners should consider climate and temperature sensitivity when choosing between screw drives and other openers.
-
Finally, jackshafts are installed on the wall beside the garage door where it connects to the door's torsion bar or shaft instead of the ceiling as the other three are. They are incredibly quiet and durable, and a popular choice for those who want to free up their ceiling space and make an opener as unnoticeable as possible.
Understanding Garage Door Openers
Chain Drive Opener
Chain drive garage door openers operate by using a metal chain that is attached to a motor and guided along a track to lift or lower the garage door. This style of operator is known for being durable and able to handle even the heaviest of garage doors. It is also one of the cheaper openers, making it a cost-effective option if price is a factor.
However, chain drives can be very noisy during operation and may shake slightly. This can be disruptive in attached garages or tightly packed neighborhoods. These systems may also require periodic maintenance, such as lubrication of the chain and gears.
Belt Drive Openers
Belt drives use a belt made of rubber or synthetic materials instead of a chain. The belt absorbs vibrations and reduces noise, resulting in much quieter operation. This makes them ideal for homes where noise is a concern.
They are typically more expensive than chain drives, but the quiet operation and reliability make it worth the investment. Belt drives are durable, though their lifespan may not exceed that of a metal chain.
Screw Drive Openers
Screw drives use a threaded steel rod that rotates to move the door. They’re great for garages with low ceilings and have fewer moving parts, which means fewer chances of malfunction.
However, they are sensitive to extreme temperature changes and may not perform well in such conditions. They are quieter than chain drives but not as quiet as belt drive systems.
Jackshaft Openers
Jackshafts mount to the wall beside the garage door and operate by turning the torsion bar. They free up ceiling space, making them great for garages with limited headroom or aesthetic concerns. They’re quiet and have fewer moving parts, which results in low maintenance needs.
Jackshafts are more expensive and require a torsion spring door system. Not all garages are compatible with jackshafts, so check installation requirements first.
Choosing the Right Garage Door Opener
| Opener Type | Noise Level | Maintenance | Cost | Durability | Space Efficiency |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Chain Drive | Loud | Average | Affordable | 10–15 years | Takes up ceiling space |
| Belt Drive | Quiet | Average | Low–mid | 10–15 years | Takes up ceiling space |
| Screw Drive | Quieter | High in extreme temps | Average | 10–15 years | Takes up ceiling space |
| Jackshaft | Quietest | Low | Higher | 15–20 years | Frees up ceiling space |
The ideal garage opener depends on your garage's layout and your lifestyle preferences. Some openers include backup batteries to keep your garage accessible during power outages.
Many newer models also offer smart technology like myQ or Aladdin Connect, allowing you to operate and monitor your garage door via a smartphone. Some are compatible with Amazon Key, letting delivery drivers place packages securely inside your garage.
A basic opener with smart features can sometimes cost more than a standard chain drive, but the convenience may be worth the upgrade.
Garage setup also matters. If your garage has a low ceiling, overhead openers may not fit well. If you’re in a region with extreme temperatures, avoid screw drives. Chain drives may be too noisy for homes with bedrooms above the garage.
With so many variables, choosing the right opener can feel overwhelming. Consulting a professional is a smart step to make sure you’re getting the best fit. Action Direct has experienced staff ready to help you pick the right model and ensure compatibility with your garage. Contact us today!
Installation and Maintenance Tips
Jackshafts have fewer parts and are easier to install, while chain and belt drives often require more complex setups. Always ensure your door is properly balanced before installing any opener.
Important: If any installation step involves adjusting a torsion spring, STOP and call a professional. Torsion springs are dangerous and can cause serious injury or death if mishandled.
Even the best openers need periodic checks. Listen for strange sounds or rough movement. Apply lubrication to moving parts like gears to reduce wear and extend the system’s lifespan.
Raise Your Door Higher with Action Direct
Garage door openers typically last 10–15 years. Choosing the right one now is a long-term investment. Reach out to our team for help with your opener questions.
Once you’ve picked your perfect opener, consider sealing your garage door to keep pests, weather, and dirt out. And keep your system in top shape with regular maintenance—check out our handy garage blog for tips.